“‘Here/Now’ starts off dreamy but builds and builds to cinemascope levels of orchestration […] Somebody hire him to write a Bond theme.” - Brooklyn Vegan
“Andrew Carroll offers up a cinematic set of psychedelic pop songs—think Pet Sounds re-envisioned as a soundtrack to a lost noir gem” -Aquarium Drunkard
“Space-age psych-pop from TV’s Lodge 49 sountracker: think Broadcast retro-futurism in L.A.” - Mojo Magazine
“‘Here/Now’ comes on like Air auditioning for the new James Bond theme.” - Shindig! Magazine
“Emmy voters should heed the siren call of Lodge 49’s original music.” - AV Club
“Andrew Carroll […] merits acknowledgment in Outstanding Original Music Composition […] Carroll helped create the hypnotic vibe of the show with a mix of retro tunes, obscure surf rock, baroque pop, and pseudo-Gregorian chants.” - AV club
“Soundscapes of ambient pop and fuzzed-out guitars that make it hard to tell waking life from dream. The spell is cast the moment the animated doors are thrown open in the title sequence, […] against the angelic sounds of Carroll’s theme. [T]he swelling chorus readily creates a mystical atmosphere. More elegant than any sea shanty, “I Lift My Lamp Beside The Golden Door!” nonetheless points to adventure, which Lodge 49 had in abundant supply.” -AV Club
“Lodge 49 has TV’s most wonderfully surprising soundtrack.” - Brooklyn Vegan
“Andrew Carroll's Lodge 49 score was like a lost exotica record from the '60s, all swooning strings and groovy basslines.” - Brooklyn Vegan
“Follow Me to the Golden Gate” [is] gentle and calming yet faintly otherworldly, the two-minute track plays something like a psychedelic folk lullaby. -Under the Radar Magazine
“Andrew Carroll’s […] unique score makes the on-screen action truly soar.” -Radio 8 Ball